Date:

Share:

LMNP: How to Choose Between Micro-BIC and the Actual Expenses Regime

Related Articles

Investing in a furnished property to rent out is appealing to more and more individuals, drawn in by a lighter tax burden than that of unfurnished rentals. But as soon as the first income tax return comes around, a question arises: should you stick with the flat-rate regime or opt for the actual expenses regime? The choice of tax regime under LMNP (non-professional furnished rental) status directly determines the amount of tax paid each year, sometimes for decades. Here are the criteria that should guide this decision, along with the most common mistakes to avoid.

LMNP Status at a Glance

This status, often referred to by the acronym LMNP (non-professional furnished rental), applies to anyone who rents out a furnished home without this activity being their main occupation — a situation where a rental property tax service such as 1800accountant.com can prove especially useful. Two cumulative conditions must be met: annual rental income must not exceed €23,000, and it must remain lower than the household's other income. Beyond that threshold, the landlord automatically falls into the category of professional furnished-rental landlords, with a different tax and social security regime.

Micro-BIC vs. Actual Expenses Regime: Two Opposing Approaches

The micro-BIC regime applies by default when income does not exceed €77,700 per year. It offers great simplicity: you simply report the gross amount of rent collected, and the tax authorities automatically apply a flat-rate allowance of 50% meant to represent expenses (only 30% for an unclassified tourist-furnished rental).

The actual expenses regime requires more rigor, since it involves keeping accounts and deducting the expenses actually incurred: loan interest, renovation work, property tax, management fees. Its main advantage is that it allows depreciation of the property and furniture, an accounting charge that involves no cash outflow but reduces — sometimes to zero — taxable income for several years.

The Criteria That Should Guide Your Choice

  • The amount of actual expenses: the higher they are (a recent loan, renovation work, condo fees), the more attractive the actual expenses regime becomes compared with the 50% flat-rate allowance.
  • How the property is financed: a purchase financed with a mortgage loan generates deductible interest that favors the actual expenses regime, especially when interest rates are high.
  • The intended holding period: over the long term, the depreciation allowed under the actual expenses regime nearly always ends up outweighing the simplicity of the micro-BIC regime.
  • The time you can devote to administrative management, or the budget planned for an accountant, which is essential in practice to secure the depreciation calculations.

This comparison isn't unique to furnished rentals: owners weighing different tax setups for an unfurnished rental property also benefit from comparing it with the rental deficit (déficit foncier) mechanism, which is reserved for unfurnished rentals but follows a similar logic: deducting actual expenses rather than accepting a flat-rate allowance.

Mistakes to Avoid

The first mistake is to stay on the micro-BIC regime by default without ever calculating the alternative, when a simple expense worksheet is often enough to settle the question. The second is choosing the actual expenses regime without anticipating the administrative burden it involves: tax filings, asset records, tracking depreciation. The third, more costly mistake, is failing to properly assess the property before putting it up for rent: whether you choose to rent out an apartment that's older or a newly built home, the depreciable base and the level of expenses to expect are not the same, and they directly affect how beneficial the actual expenses regime will be. Finally, opting for the actual expenses regime commits you for a minimum period of several years: it cannot be changed from one tax year to the next.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can You Change Tax Regimes Along the Way?

Yes, a landlord under the micro-BIC regime can opt for the actual expenses regime before the tax return filing deadline. The choice is irrevocable for several years, which means it needs to be carefully thought through in advance.

Is the Actual Expenses Regime Always More Advantageous?

No. For an older property with no loan and few expenses, the 50% flat-rate allowance under the micro-BIC regime may be enough to cover actual costs, making the actual expenses regime needlessly complicated.

Is an Accountant Required Under the Actual Expenses Regime?

It's not a legal requirement, but calculating accounting depreciation is technical, and a mistake can be costly in the event of an audit: most landlords using the actual expenses regime hire a professional.

Sources

This article was written with the help of artificial intelligence. Editorial policy

Popular Articles

Editorial policy and use of artificial intelligence